Raid on Bible Society of Malaysia Legally Unfounded, Critics Say

Bibles seized, BSM leaders temporarily detained.

Worship in Malay language at church in Seremban, Malaysia in 2009. (Wikipedia)

Worship in Malay language at church in Seremban, Malaysia in 2009. (Wikipedia)

KUALA LUMPUR, Malaysia (Morning Star News) – Calling this month’s raid on the Bible Society of Malaysia (BSM) “a flagrant violation of religious liberty” via his website, the director of a Christian research institute in Malaysia said the agency that arrested two BSM officials has produced no evidence that the BSM violated any law.

Aided by police, the Selangor Islamic Affairs Department (JAIS) on Jan. 2 raided BSM offices in Damansara Kim, near Kuala Lumpur, without a search warrant, causing an uproar in the Christian community and among opposition lawmakers and civil society groups.

JAIS did not provide reasons for the raid. The religious agency was purportedly acting under the Selangor Non-Islamic Religions (Control of Propagation Among Muslims) Enactment of 1988, which prohibits non-Muslims from using more than 40 religious terms, including “Allah,” an Arabic word that also serves as the Malay word for God. The word “Allah” appears in copies of the Bibles that were seized during the raid.

Ng Kam Weng, research director at the Kairos Research Centre, emphasized on that JAIS needed to produce evidence that the BSM had violated the Enactment in propagating another faith to Muslims in order to justify the raid – something it has failed to do.

The newly formed National Unity Consultative Council (NUCC), tasked by the government to come up with a blueprint for national unity, described the raid as a “blatant disregard for the 10-point solution made by the Federal Government on April 2, 2011 and reiterated by the Prime Minister in October 2013.”

In the 10-point solution, the government had assured Christians in East Malaysia that they were free to print and import Malay-language Bibles for their Christian practice. The solution also allowed Malay-language Bibles to be printed or brought into West Malaysia so long as they bear the symbol of the cross and the words, “Christian publication” on the front cover.

“When the 10-point solution was first announced, the Christian Federation of Malaysia had commented that it was an ad-hoc, temporary solution arising from the impounding of Bibles and does not address the root cause of the problem,” Ng of the Kairos center told Morning Star News. “What is needed is to set aside the original administrative order banning use of the word ‘Allah.’ The final resolution must come from the legal process.”

During the raid, JAIS confiscated 330 Bibles – 320 copies of the Malay Bible and 10 copies in Iban, an indigenous language. JAIS also detained BSM President Lee Min Choon and office manager Sinclair Wong for questioning at the nearby Damansara police station.

Both were released on bail after two hours without charge, but police instructed them to present themselves for further questioning by JAIS on Friday (Jan. 10). JAIS is a state religious agency under the purview of the Selangor Islamic Religious Council (MAIS), which was established to aid and advise the sultan, who is the head of Islam within the state, on Islamic matters. Both MAIS and JAIS have no jurisdiction over non-Muslims.

In an attempt to resolve the issue, both Lee and Wong of the BSM met with JAIS’ officers on Friday (Jan. 10) as instructed by the police, though The Malaysian Insider reported that Lee said they went “voluntarily.” Lee told the newspaper that no one at the meeting with JAIS had forbidden them from continuing to import and distribute Bibles, and that officers only asked about their origin and distribution.

In the immediate wake of the raid, BSM had issued a strongly-worded press statement condemning the raid and saying, “JAIS, whose legal powers are limited to policing Muslims, are now exercising powers over non-Muslims.”

Lee had also suggested that blame for the raid and Bible seizure should go to the Selangor state government since JAIS is a state agency, and he urged the state government to endorse the 10-point solution issued by the federal government to resolve the issue.

The raid on BSM came in the wake of a statement made by the Rev. Lawrence Andrew, editor of Catholic newspaper The Herald, to The Malaysian Insider on Dec. 27 saying Catholic churches will continue to use the word “Allah” in Malay-language worship services despite the Sultan of Selangor’s recent decree banning non-Muslims in the state from doing so.

Widespread Criticism

Both the minister who announced the 10-point solution, Idris Jala, and the prime minister have remained conspicuously silent since the raid.

The CFM, which represents the majority of Christians in the country, described JAIS’s actions in a Jan. 3 press statement as “clear violations of our constitutionally-mandated right to freedom of religion” and “an authoritarian abuse of power and an act of harassment against Christians in Malaysia.”

“To allow one religion to be able to monitor and regulate how another religion is to be practiced is a distasteful recipe for disaster,” said the Rev. Eu Hong Seng, chairman of the CFM.

The National Evangelical Christian Fellowship (NECF), in a letter to church leaders on Jan. 3, argued that the ban against non-Muslims using “Allah” under the Enactment is “only within the context of the propagation of religion and does not affect our rights to profess and to manage our own affairs, including to worship and read the Alkitab [the Malay Bible] in churches, homes and any place of Christian meetings.”

A number of local observers and Christian leaders disagreed with Lee on how the issue can and should be resolved. They argue that the 10-point solution is merely an administrative document issued by the federal government.

As such, many in the Christian community are eagerly waiting for the outcome of a hearing by the Federal Court, which on Feb. 24 will decide whether to allow an appeal by The Herald to use the word “Allah” in the Malay-language section of its publication that is circulated among church members.

“JAIS had gone overboard by seizing the Malay-language Bibles from BSM, as the body was clearly set up to publish and distribute Bibles to Christians,” human rights lawyer Andrew Khoo reportedly said.

Sunni Islam is the official religion in Malayia, whose population is 62.6 percent Muslim, according to Operation World. Christians make up 9.4 percent of the population.


© 2014 Morning Star News. Articles/photos may be reprinted with credit to Morning Star News.

Morning Star News is a 501(c)(3) non-profit corporation that relies solely on contributions to offer original news reports of persecuted Christians. Our mission is to inform those in the free world and in countries violating religious freedom about Christians worldwide who are persecuted for their faith. For free subscription or to make tax-deductible donations, contact [email protected], or send check to Morning Star News, 24310 Moulton Parkway, Suite O # 157, Laguna Hills, CA 92637, USA.


Speak Your Mind